When people search for the “most challenging dogs to train,” they are usually facing one of two situations. Either they are considering a breed and want to make an informed decision, or they are already living with a highly intelligent, strong-willed, or reactive dog and feel overwhelmed.
The truth is that no dog is “bad” or “untrainable.” However, some breeds are genetically wired with traits that make training more demanding. High intelligence, strong prey drive, independence, and protective instincts can all create challenges without the right structure and guidance.
Below, we explore five breeds widely regarded as the most challenging to train — and explain why.
The Belgian Malinois is often described as one of the most intelligent and capable working breeds in the world. Frequently used in military and police roles, they thrive when given purpose and structured outlets for their energy.
However, that same intensity can make them extremely challenging in a domestic setting.
Why They’re Challenging
A Belgian Malinois without structure will create its own job, and that job may involve destructive behaviour, excessive barking, reactivity, or over-attachment. They require confident, experienced handling and daily engagement.
When properly trained, they are extraordinary companions. Without leadership, they can become overwhelming.
Siberian Huskies are stunning, charismatic dogs with a history of pulling sleds across vast distances. They were bred for endurance, teamwork, and independent problem-solving.
That independence is exactly what makes them difficult to train.
Why They’re Challenging
Huskies often understand commands perfectly well — they simply decide whether responding suits them. Owners frequently struggle with off-lead control and consistent obedience.
Training a Husky requires patience, clarity, and realistic expectations. They are not disobedient; they are self-directed.
German Shepherds are widely recognised as one of the most versatile working breeds. They are intelligent, loyal, and capable of high-level obedience.
But their strengths can also become challenges.
Why They’re Challenging
German Shepherds need balanced leadership. Without proper socialisation and structure, they may develop anxiety, over-guarding behaviours, or reactivity toward strangers or other dogs.
Their intelligence means they pick up patterns quickly — including inconsistency. Training must be calm, clear, and structured.
Often ranked as the most intelligent dog breed, the Border Collie excels at learning complex tasks. Originally bred to herd livestock, they are wired for focus, control, and responsiveness.
But extreme intelligence comes with demands.
Why They’re Challenging
Border Collies thrive when given a structured outlet. Without it, they may develop compulsive behaviours such as shadow chasing, spinning, or excessive barking.
They are not difficult because they cannot learn — they are difficult because they need far more engagement than most owners expect.
Dachshunds are often underestimated because of their size. Originally bred to hunt badgers, they are bold, determined, and surprisingly stubborn.
Their independence can make training surprisingly complex.
Why They’re Challenging
Because they are small, owners sometimes allow behaviours they would not tolerate in larger breeds. Over time, this can create ingrained habits that are harder to change.
Consistent boundaries and structured training are essential, even for small breeds such as Dachshunds.
The common thread among these breeds is not lack of intelligence. In fact, the opposite is true. Many of the most challenging breeds are among the most intelligent.
The difficulty usually arises from:
When natural instincts are misunderstood or unmanaged, behaviour issues develop.
Absolutely.
In fact, with proper structure and guidance, these breeds can become some of the most impressive and loyal companions available.
The key elements are:
For higher-drive or reactive dogs, immersive and structured training environments can often accelerate progress by removing distractions and providing daily consistency.
If you are considering one of these breeds, research and preparation are essential. Understanding their working history helps set realistic expectations.
If you already own one and are struggling, you are not alone. Many owners of intelligent, high-drive breeds reach a point where professional guidance becomes invaluable.
The right support does not suppress personality. Instead, it channels natural instincts into controlled, manageable behaviours.
The most challenging dogs to train are rarely “bad dogs.” They are intelligent, driven, independent, or sensitive animals whose needs exceed the average owner’s expectations.
When those needs are met with structure, patience, and expertise, these breeds often transform from overwhelming to outstanding.
In the right environment, with the right leadership, even the most demanding breed can thrive.
© 2026 Next Level Dog Training. All rights reserved.